PRODPLN1/2.MOD PRODPLN1.MOD PRODPLN2.MOD Time ChPt Iter Time ChPt Iter ILOG SOLVER 4.0 1stUnbound 24.59 49914 24.02 49914 MinSize .61 1985 .60 1985 BestGen 1stUnbound 24.65 49914 24.08 49914 MinSize .51 1822 .51 1822 OSL 1.2 pretype 1 171.00 43579 34432 pretype 2 170.00 43579 34432 ILOG PLANNER 2.2 Up, Most 110.63 34961 15099 12.97 3701 3904 Dn, Most 57.88 19816 8925 10.26 3183 3236 Up, Least 264.39 88442 41205 3.87 1052 1297 Dn, Least 459.79 148284 66831 18.76 4919 5548 ILOG PLANNER 2.0 Up, Most 133.80 52750 139376 18.03 6434 18733 Dn, Most 47.39 19079 50704 12.37 4246 13100 Up, Least 208.71 77799 183850 3.06 993 3026 Dn, Least 550.36 193356 473975 16.40 5239 16338 CPLEX 5.0 Most 1.07 2238 2398 .86 1807 1910 Least 39.20 88373 85215 .78 1679 1718 Pseudo 6.33 13625 13561 1.01 2184 2184 Strong 6.71 4141 5121 1.18 1020 1059 Best est Most 12.65 2921 26653 1.92 4287 4296 Least 42.79 96182 93219 1.08 2332 2308 Pseudo 5.46 11554 11503 .98 2157 2158 Strong 7.69 4444 5442 1.11 924 960