Detection Limits in Chemical Analysis
Tuesday 3 June, 10:20--12:10
- Organizer: Ha NGUYEN
- Merck Research Laboratories
- Moderator: Ha NGUYEN
- Merck Research Laboratories
- Diane LAMBERT
- Bell Laboratories, Lucent Technologies, Murray Hill, NJ, USA
- Luke TIERNEY
- University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, MN, USA
The first step in many environmental measurement processes is to
separate the pollutant of interest from every other compound in the
sample. This step is not error-free, however. Thus, in gas
chromatograph/mass spectroscopy, for example, the isolated compound is
tested to verify that it is the pollutant of interest. If the
isolated compound passes the tests, then its measurement is reported
numerically. Otherwise, the measurement is reported as ``nondetect''
and its numerical value may (or may not) be suppressed. In at least
some applications, the verification tests are designed so that there
are no false positives, but there may be false negatives. Usually, the
probability of verifying a measurement depends on its size. The
question is how can the mean concentration of the pollutant be
estimated when some measurements are known to be from the pollutant,
others may or may not be from the pollutant, the probability of
verifying a measurement on the pollutant depends on its size, and
neither the shape of the distribution of the pollutant nor the shape
of the probability of verification function is known? This talk
proposes new nonparametric answers to this question and applies them
to data from a Love Canal study.
[Diane Lambert, Bell Laboratories, Lucent Technologies; Room 2C-256, 600 Mountain
Ave., Murray Hill, NJ USA 07974, dl@bell-labs.com]
- L. A. CURRIE
- National Institute of Standards and Technology, Gaithersburg, MD, USA
When one wishes to perform "Measurements below the detectable limit,"
two
broad issues must be addressed. First, what is the "detectable
limit;" second, how
can you proceed if the measurement requirements exceed the detection
(or quantification) capabilities? The first question has been the
subject of debate for
decades, both in terms of nomenclature and in terms of evaluation.
Happily, the resolution to this matter appears close at hand, as a
result of deliberations by the
International Union of Pure and Applied Chemistry (IUPAC) and the
International Organization for Standardization (ISO). IUPAC and ISO
addressed this issue in a joint meeting in 1993, and since that time
IUPAC has published recommendations (Pure and Applied Chemistry v. 67,
pp 1699-1723, 1995), and
ISO has prepared a draft document on the topic. The talk will begin
with a brief
review of these international deliberations and recommendations.
The second question is, in many respects, the more challenging and
interesting; it will represent the focus of the talk. Approaching
measurements beyond the state of the current art offers special
opportunities for synergistic collaboration
between scientists and statisticians, through careful analysis of the
structure of the
measurement process, to designed experiments to assess statistical and
physicochemical limitations, and especially to open the way for
"statistical thinking" and "scientific intuition" to define totally
new ways of approaching the
measurement problem, yielding significantly reduced detection
(quantification) limits. Illustrations will be given of successful
reinvention of the measurement
process, drawn from fields ranging from radiocarbon dating to the
measurement of low levels of atmospheric radioactivity. Time
permitting, the talk will conclude
with a brief introduction to the use of "Standard Test Data" to reveal
the real measurement limitations of chemical and physical measurement
systems incorporating "black box" software and subconscious operator
decisions.
[L. A. Currie, National Institute of Standards and Technology, Gaithersburg, MD 20899]
Back to JRC program
Back to JRC Home Page