The Mother and the Whore

Written and Directed by Jean Eustache

Movie Review by Derek Dreyer

I've always had a love/hate relationship with the French New Wave -- a highly influential movement in cinema that began in the late '50s with "auteurs" like Godard and Truffaut and attempted to explore complex issues such as sex and politics by reinventing cinematic language. Although I appreciate the goals of the New Wave, I find most of the French films of this period to be endlessly pretentious, incomprehensible and/or boring. But not all. At three-and-a-half hours, Jean Eustache's black-and-white 1973 anti-epic The Mother and the Whore might seem a likely candidate for background noise during a nice long nap. Much to my surprise, I didn't even yawn.

The film, which examines the sex life of a quasi-intellectual named Alexandre (played by New Wave icon Jean-Pierre Leaud), appears to have no plot. Well, a little one: Alexandre lives with a woman about ten years his senior named Marie ("the mother", played by Bernadette Lafont) who loves him and takes care of him. In the first sequence of the film, he wakes up and drives off to try to woo back an ex-girlfriend. She almost immediately rejects his pleading and informs him that she is getting married to someone else. Soon after, he sees a pretty girl named Veronika ("the whore", played by Francoise Lebrun in an impressive debut) at a cafe, he gets her phone number, and they spend the rest of the film trying to sort out their relationship.

From the first ten minutes of the film it is clear that Alexandre is a self-important jerk and it is hard to imagine how his (sex) life could be interesting at all. I think one reason why it becomes interesting is that Eustache does not romanticize it. He focuses in on Alexandre's life so closely that we are no longer watching an intellectual fable about relationships, such as in the films of New Waver Eric Rohmer, but a true slice of the "nothing" life. All Alexandre does every day is go down to the cafe, meet Veronika and other assorted intellectual friends, run his mouth off a lot, have sex occasionally, and come home in the evening to Marie. Eustache even includes scenes in which the characters simply sit and listen to songs on a record player. The essential emptiness of Alexandre's existence, a kind of existence encouraged perhaps by French society, is laid bare by the film's objective non-judgmental style.

Of course, this style of film always prompts the question, at least in my head: "How can a film about boredom and emptiness not be boring in itself?" Often it can. For instance, I find films like Antonioni's L'Avventura, a highly regarded meditation on the emptiness of the rich, and Richard Linklater's Slacker, an experimental film which followed various do-nothings around Texas, completely soporific. But the problem with those films is that they either condescend to the characters or do not focus long enough on them to really give one the sense of what it feels like to live a completely empty life.

In some ways, The Mother and the Whore also reminded me of Manhattan, the great Woody Allen film from 1979. Although it's a very different movie, Manhattan is in a way "The Daughter and the Whore." Woody Allen's character dumps his loving, down-to-earth 17-year-old girlfriend ("the daughter") for a quasi-intellectual sexually-experienced woman his own age ("the whore", played by Diane Keaton). Only at the end does he realize what matters to him in life, albeit by then it's too late. In Eustache's film, Alexandre makes no such realization, but he does at some point see how childishly he has acted toward the one woman who is capable of love, Marie, and his reaction is simply to stop talking.

If there was any problem I had with The Mother and the Whore, it was the lack of development of the "mother" character Marie. The film really focuses on exploring Veronika and doesn't try to give any explanation as to why Marie would even find comfort in such a twerp as Alexandre. Are/were French men really that focused on youth that they wouldn't see the utter loveliness of Lafont's Marie?

Early in the film, Alexandre's ex-girlfriend responds drily to his incessant admissions of passion for her: "I really hope you work it out." The Mother and the Whore is a film that tries to do just that by looking at life under a magnifying glass. In 1981, Eustache committed suicide. I suppose that either he wasn't able to "work it out" or what he found under the surface of his life was too sad to bear.