Reunion begins with an intriguing montage. First, the
shuffling of footsteps as a group of men are led into a stark
room to be executed, then a child playing on a swing, followed by
a young man entering a classroom, and finally Jason Robards
sitting in a trance on a park bench, suddenly awaking to the
screams of his granddaughter as she is chased by a dog. Catchy
opening, but can we really expect a movie on Holocaust-related
themes nowadays to unravel this dream in a new and edifying way?
No matter. The film, written by playwright Harold Pinter
(Betrayal) and directed by Jerry Schatzberg (The Panic in Needle
Park), approaches its material with a lean, almost conventional,
style that allows its power to seep in slowly and surely, its
mysteries to be explained in due course. There are no jolts, no
shocks. The Holocaust didn't happen in a day.
After the Robards character, Henry (Hans) Strauss, informs his
daughter that he has to "take care of this...thing," we
follow him back to his hometown of Stuttgart, Germany, which he
has not visited since he lived there as a teenager, fifty years
prior. The town has of course changed, it has lost some of the
idyllic German beauty we see much of in the long flashback that
dominates the film, it has become more like the rest of the
world.
As a young man in 1932, Hans (Christien Anholt) befriends the
wealthiest and brightest student in his class, Konradin von
Lohenburg (Samuel West), who seems reluctant to invite him into
his palatial home. We learn later that there is good reason for
this: Hans is a Jew and Konradin's mother an anti-Semite. In
fact, as we and Hans learn, casual anti-Semitism is rampant in
Stuttgart, although Nazism hasn't quite taken a stronghold yet,
and Hans' father, a World War I veteran and proud German, is
confident the German people will see through all the
"rubbish."
Needless to say, they don't. Much of the film is devoted to the
poignant interaction between Hans and Konradin as they muse about
God, politics and sex (which they decide at one point is
tantamount to "eating a sandwich" to satisfy one's
hunger), in the midst of an increasingly volatile social
situation. Thankfully it doesn't beat us over the head with some
overbearing sense of purpose, but rather subtly uses the two
boys' tenuous friendship to generate a genuine longing for what
might have been and fear of what actually was.
Of course, any "Holocaust flashback" film, as one might
bluntly categorize this one, must end up being compared to Alan
J. Pakula's stunning Sophie's Choice, and Jason Robards is no
Meryl Streep. Then again, Reunion is not presenting the Holocaust
from the point of view of one who lived through it, but of one
who feels a void for having left before anything happened. In the
framing episodes, Strauss searches for his boyhood friend,
although no one he speaks to is particularly helpful. Perhaps the
Germans are just tired of pesky, fully Americanized Jews trying
to reclaim their homeland. Or perhaps it is easier to simply
memorialize the atrocities of yesteryear and forget them.
Reunion was shown last Thursday as part of the Jewish/Israeli
film festival at the Carnegie Museum of Art, which continues
sporadically throughout the next month. As far as I can tell, it
is not available on video, which is extremely unfortunate.