Student Paper Competition: FAQ

Student Paper Competition: Frequently Asked Questions

Exactly who is eligible for the competition?

Anyone who is a student (graduate or undergraduate) at a university. We do ask for a faculty member (usually the student's mentor or advisor) to certify student status in the fall term before the competition. In the past, all of the entrants have been graduate students, but undergraduates could make substantial contributions in a new field like statistical computing. We do ask for a CV as well so that the committee judging the entries can be calibrated about an entrant's educational level.

One correspondent asked if high school students could enter. We don't prohibit this, but realistically high school students might be at a disadvantage against graduate students close to finishing their PhD.

Why is the deadline so close to the beginning of the year and the end of the winter holidays?

We want to give entrants who are not selected the opportunity to submit their paper to the Joint Statistical Meetings as a regular contributed paper. The deadline for this is usually at the very beginning of February. So in order to get the papers to the committee, have them read the papers, discuss them, and make a decision, and inform those who are selected and those who are not, we need an early submission deadline.

Why do you print out papers?

Several reasons. The short decision time, the fact that the members of the committee may have different computer environments, and the desire to present each member with a standard package which they may begin working on immediately all drive our current procedure of printing out each entry and FedExing a package to each committee member. Also, each member either teaches or works in industry and we try to relieve them of the need to individually print out each entry.

What does the letter from the faculty member need to contain?

Two things:
  • A certification of your student status in the fall term before the competition.
  • If the paper is jointly authored, an indication as to how much is your work.
We recommend that you ask your advisor to send the letter early, if possible before the holidays because people are often late getting back and the time span between the end of the holidays and the deadline is very short. We will open a file for your entry when we receive the letter and wait for the rest of the materials to arrive.

Do you acknowledge submissions?

We do acknowledge by email only, so be sure to include an email address. If you want to call me I will acknowledge receipt of your entry by phone. I don't have staff to do a mail acknowledgment.

Can you give some examples of previous winners?

Yes. In previous years, the Journal of Computational and Graphical Statistics has printed papers from the winners. See the following issues: September 1998, September 1999, and December 2000; each has a special section fors the student papers.

Lionel Galway
Senior Statistician
The RAND Corporation
1700 Main St.
Santa Monica, CA 90401
voice: 310-393-0411 X7957
fax: 310-393-4818
email: Lionel_Galway@rand.org

Posted November 2001