The Computing Section offers first Referee process at JSM 2002

This year, the Section on Statistical Computing is introducing an experimental refereeing process for contributed papers submitted to the Joint Statistical Meetings. We see this service as helping our members in two ways.

  • First, by introducing some form of refereeing we can highlight outstanding contributed papers on statistical computing.

    You know how difficult it can be to navigate the 20 or so parallel sessions at the annual meetings, especially when your only compass is a set of 250-word abstracts. Those papers that pass the refereeing process will receive more prominent positioning in the JSM program. We will also distribute the extended abstracts for these papers, providing you with an informative guide to some of the best computing talks at the meeting.

  • Secondly, we hope to improve the overall quality of contributed papers and presentations at the JSM.

    Authors will receive feedback from the referees about their papers, and will be expected to incorporate improvements for their presentations. In return for the elevated status of the accepted papers in the JSM program, we will also set high expectations for presentation quality.

Before I explain the details of this new procedure, let me emphasize that what we are proposing is entirely voluntary. If you do not want to participate, you can still contribute an abstract to the Section as you have done in the past (using the submission form at www.amstat.org). However, we hope that this process will become a popular method for submitting papers to the JSM.

Here is what we are planning for 2002. Each author wishing to participate in the refereeing process will be required to submit an extended abstract for their JSM paper by January 4, 2002. An extended abstract is at most three pages in length and must provide a fairly complete picture of the author's paper. Keep in mind that the very short abstracts we typically submit to the JSM are not of sufficient detail to be meaningfully refereed.

The extended abstracts will then be sent to a Program Committee headed by the Computing Section's Program Chair (this year, Tim Hesterberg from Insightful Corporation). On the basis of this committee's evaluations, the best papers will be assigned to Topic Contributed Sessions entitled "Computing Section Refereed Papers: Topic XYZ." All decisions will be made before February 1, 2002. The extended abstracts for the accepted papers will be made available through the Computing Section's Web site www.statcomputing.org prior to the JSM. Accepted papers will also receive a special notation in the Proceedings for the Computing Section. Those papers that are not selected by the Program Committee will receive a slot in a Regular Contributed Session, as will abstracts from authors choosing not to participate.

I encourage you to consider this new procedure as you think about your paper for JSM 2002. If you have any comments, please feel free to contact the Section Chair at chair@statcomputing.org.

Important Dates:

Due Date:
January 4, 2002

Instructions for submission available:
November 1, 2001


Updated October 2001