In July, 1998, I decided to go shopping for a more ergonomic keyboard for my office X-terminal. The X-terminal, a Tektronix XP350-series X-terminal, accepts PC-compatible keyboards. For example, before I took my Microsoft Natural keyboard home for use on my home PC some years ago, I tried that keyboard out on my XP350 X-terminal. It worked fine.
My current keyboard on that X-terminal is a very ordinary "PS/2-style" keyboard from Tektronix. In its favor, it has a nice feel, and has proven to be durable through years of hard use. But I type at my office keyboard many hours each day, and the literature keeps telling me that I'd be wise to have an arrangement that is easy to use with my wrists straight. A conventional computer keyboard doesn't meet that requirement.
My intention had been to post links here to the various other keyboard vendors that I'd found, but I never got around to it. I also found a vendor for stickers to mark the keycaps for a Dvorak layout and I experimented for a while with having my PC keyboard configured in a Dvorak layout. It didn't seem to make any radical improvement and it did make my fingers get confused when I'd move between keyboards. Rather then impose Dvorak layouts on every PC I touch (in my home, in my office, in the lab, the group's notebook PC, ...), I concluded it was easier to just stick with the conventional QWERTY layout. Similarly, I've decided not to fight the trend to keyboards with the esc key way up on the top left instead of in the numbers row, and the caps-lock key where God intended the control key to be (next to the A key). Now that pretty much all my keyboards have that layout, my fingers have gotten used to it. I conclude that the hassles come from having mixed layouts of the keyboards in your life. For me, the MS-Natural split keyboard plain old QWERTY layout seems to be good enough.
A couple of long and rambling articles about keyboards have been posted on the "Tom's Hardware" web site. The author of those, Omid Rahmat, apparently is happily using an MS-Natural keyboard, but is trying to snag evaluation copies of more radical alternatives so he can at least try them. Here's a link to Second Hand Smoke - Extreme Keyboard (5/1/2001) and if you enjoyed the smoke he was blowing, then you'll also want to read the 2nd of his articles Second Hand Smoke - Extreme Keyboard II (5/4/2001)
If you are looking to try something more radical, you might want to take a look at the reduced motion keypads from Datahand. Unfortunately, the price on these is high enough (around $1,000) that I haven't dared to consider experimenting with them.
Real Soon Now, the USB (Universal Serial Bus) plug is likely to take the place of the conventional mini-DIN-connector for connecting keyboards and mice to PC's. Interrupt Request Lines (IRQ's) on PC's are scarce, and using USB for the keyboard and mouse will use 1 IRQ (for the USB interface) while freeing up 2 IRQ's (formerly needed for the keyboard and for the mouse). Linux has recently had USB support added. In the Microsoft world, USB support for Windows 95 is kind of dicey from what I hear and I don't think you can get it at all for Windows NT 4.0 or older. I haven't tried USB support in WIndows 2000, but I believe its in there.
The current model of the Microsoft Natural keyboard, the "Elite" model, already offers both a conventional keyboard connector and a USB interface. (My own Microsoft Natural Keyboard is much older than the "Elite" model and has only a conventional PC keyboard connector on it. I notice that the "elite" model apparently had some changes to the layout of the kays to reduce the overall width of the keyboard. I haven't tried it, but I sure hope that didn't change the usability of the keyboard.).
I mention this change to a USB interface so you know to check on the keyboard interface used on your PC before you order a keyboard, and so you'll know that the keyboard you buy today may not have the right interface for re-use on a PC that you buy somewhere out in the future.
In addition, you should also be aware that in their eternal quest for product differentiation, some PC manufacturers are adding buttons and features to their keyboards, such as "Message waiting" lights, CD player controls and so forth.
For example, the Gateway Multifunction Keyboard, apparently now discontinued, had CD, volume, answering machine, radio and power controls embedded in the keyboard.
I mention those extra features so you know that you may have to forego some of those fancy extras if you substitute an ergonomic keyboard for one of those keyboards that have non-standard enhancements like that. I do not know if you can use programmable keys to get equivalent functionality without having the manufacturer's "differentiated" keyboard. Caveat Emptor.
Microsoft has apparently noticed this too and has introduced their Microsoft Natural Keyboard Pro that has 19 extra keys for "superior control over your PC". I haven't tried this one.
Software came with the MS-Natural Keyboard for use with Windows-NT 3.51. My perception was that the frequency of system crashes went up after I'd installed that software. (I confess to not having measurements to demonstrate that my perception is correct).
When I eventually upgraded to Windows-NT 4.0 SP3, I didn't install any keyboard-specific software onto the system. The MS-Natural Keyboard still works fine. I believe that whatever minor features I'd have been missing on NT 3.51 without the additional software, is built into NT 4.0.
I use that keyboard every day and like it a lot. But my children have given the keyboard a try and didn't much like it. I think they could get used to it if they spent more time with it, but it does take a little getting used to. (My eleven-year-old daughter has hands much smaller than mine. When she tried the diminutive keyboard of the now discontinued Toshiba Libretto 50CT sub-notebook, she loved it. Yet, I found the Libretto keyboard was far too small for my fat fingers. That left me wondering why keyboards aren't sold in sizes). The key point here is that not everyone is going to like the same things. In the end, you'll have to judge the ergonomics of products relative to your own hands, etc. for yourself.
The one fault I've noted with the MS-Natural Keyboard is a minor one. The legends on some of the keycaps (e.g. the "N" key) have apparently worn off to the point of being hard to read. I see no signs of abrasion of the keys, and haven't used any harsh cleansers on them, so I'm not sure why some of them have faded so. Fortunately, I know the QWERTY keyboard layout well enough that I don't have to read the keycaps on the keys very often.
I find the MS-Natural Keyboard does let me keep my wrists in a more ergonomically correct position when typing. My sizeable gut keeps my elbows well separated when typing, so the angled arrangement of the 2 halves of the MS-Natural Keyboard are an improvement for me over the straight line arrangement of a conventional keyboard.
Another MS-Natural Keyboard is certainly a candidate for use on my office X-terminal. The only reason I'm shopping around is to see if I can find something that is even better than that. The angle and separation of the MS-Natural Keyboard is fixed. I speculate that a split keyboard with adjustable angles might be better than the one-size-fits-all fixed angle. But the price and bulk of some of the alternatives, may very well drive me back to the MS-Natural Keyboard.
I have another page in which I was looking for programmable keyboards and keypads. There is some product overlap of that page with this one.
If you have comments about ergonomic keyboards, including suggestions of sites, manufacturers or models that I should have mentioned and didn't, or stories that we should consider in making our choices, or find any of these links to be broken, please contact me via e-mail.
Up to Drew's Office Ergonomic Investigations page.
Up to R. Drew Davis (internal) Bell Labs Home page.
Last modified May 08, 2001