hardware, don't talk to me about hardware...
Have I told you lately that I hate hardware?
It too often seems to have been designed by the dumbest people on the planet,
and that's when it's in working order,
which isn't often enough.
too many crappy connectors
Serial cable wiring is the current bane of my existence,
and Ethernet (since 10base-T) did do a much better job with connectors,
but there's still far too much creativity with connectors.
What's wrong with the good, old 8-wire RJ45 connector?
Almost nothing needs more than 8 leads these days,
yet I see a profusion of new connectors for every new whiz-bang.
Does USB really need Yet Another New Incompatible Connector?
Even when more leads are needed (e.g. SCSI),
why do we have to have 4 or 5 different connectors,
and why do they have to be such a pain to insert,
especially in badly-lit corners?
There's a single universal generic power cord (at least in
North America) with 3-prong connectors;
I challenge the computer industry to get its data connectors down to one.
I continue to hope that wireless gizmos will enventually eliminate
all data cables.
too many bizarro screw-heads
And why can't we have 001 screw-head designs?
Who thinks up this rubbish, and why hasn't he been put to death yet?
hardware ``design''
The popular peripheral controllers don't seem have been debugged.
Having to work around bugs in hardware shouldn't be necessary.
sleazy fans & power supplies
The leading cause of computer failures seems to be cheesy fans or
power supplies that fail,
causing the rest of the system to overheat.
Is it too much to ask that vendors spend the few extra pence for reliable
versions of these?
sleazy disks
IDE hardware is gradually becoming less stupid
and it is dirt cheap, but disk manufacturers make their most reliable disks
(as determined by QA testing)
into SCSI disks, so IDE disks are pretty much guaranteed
to die sooner than you'd like or expect.
ever-changing components
Even if you buy a board with the exact same model number as one
you bought previously, the components may have changed in software-visible
ways based on prices on the spot market the morning the board was made.
And if the name or model number have changed at all,
for example incrementing the version number or
appending a letter or "Pro" or "Value Edition",
ghod help you: the thing is likely to have completely new insides
that are utterly software-incompatible with your earlier board.
A little honesty here would go a long ways:
if you've changed the guts, say so by changing the name or number
radically!
Thinking you can paper it over by changing the Windows driver you supply
doesn't cut it; we don't all run Windows.
programming documentation
It's incredibly hard to get documentation just on the programming interface
to a board these days.
See above re: Windows drivers not cutting it.
The magic `Linux' word helps some, it's like Jedi mind control with some
vendors.
Decent documentation will sell boards, so it's worth a vendor's while
to write it and give it away.
It doesn't have to be fancy, just give us the theory of operation and
what the bits in the registers do.
This leads us into ...
the role of the evil Microsoft
Aside from general illegal monopolistic business practices,
Microsoft has struck under-the-table deals with hardware vendors of the form
`we'll write Windows drivers for your boards as long as you
give your hardware documentation only to us'.
One can only hope that Microsoft will get what it deserves, and soon.
themes
So the underlying problems seem to be:
-
cheapness,
-
(usually gratuitous) incompatibilities.
Apparently the responsible people don't realise the
cost of cheapness and incompatibility.
I'm here to tell them that they are great,
and that short-term micro-optimisations are almost never worthwhile.
Geoff Collyer
geoff at collyer.net