OWL versus the Semantic Web
by Peter F. Patel-Schneider

OWL versus the Semantic Web

Abstract

OWL is now a W3C-recommended part of the Semantic Web. OWL provides an ontology layer for the Semantic Web, largely in the form of an expressive Description Logic. However, there is a tension between the design needs of a Description Logic and the W3C vision of the Semantic Web that has resulted in some significant compromises in the design of OWL. Nonetheless, OWL provides significant capabilities, both by itself and as part of a larger logic-based vision of the Semantic Web.

Acknowledgments and Caveats

Acknowledgments

This talk reports on the work of a large group of researchers, including many in the W3C RDF Core and Web Ontology Working Groups, but, of course, has my particular prejudices built into it.

Caveats

The Semantic Web

The Semantic Web Vision

Bases of the Semantic Web

The Semantic Web

A (Modest) Example

The Semantic Web Tower

Semantic Web Tower

 

Not yet specified

Not yet specified

Not yet specified

OWL ontology language

RDF provides semantics

XML provides syntax

Identifiers are URIs (IRIs)


OWL Ontology Fragment (in RDF/XML syntax)

Taken from the OWL wine and food ontologies.



<owl:Class rdf:ID="WhiteWine">
  <owl:intersectionOf rdf:parseType="Collection">
    <owl:Class rdf:about="#Wine" />
    <owl:Restriction>
      <owl:onProperty rdf:resource="#hasColor" />
      <owl:hasValue rdf:resource="#White" />
    </owl:Restriction>
  </owl:intersectionOf>
</owl:Class>

In other words

A WhiteWine is precisely a Wine that has Color White.
(From now on, I will not use the RDF/XML syntax!)

OWL Ontology Fragment (in DL syntax)

wine:Wine ≤ food:PotableLiquid ∩ (≥1 wine:madeFromGrape) ∩
                     (=1 wine:hasMaker) ∩ (∀ wine:hasMaker wine:Winery) ∩
                     (=1 wine:hasColor) ∩ ...
wine:madeFromGrape ≤ wine:Wine × wine:WineGrape
wine:hasColor ≤ wine:Wine × wine:WineColor
wine:WineColor = { wine:White, wine:Rose, wine:Red }
wine:White ≠ wine:Rose   wine:White ≠ wine:Red   wine:Rose ≠ wine:Red
wine:WineDescriptor = wine:WineTaste ∪ wine:WineColor

wine:WhiteWine = wine:Wine ∩ ( wine:hasColor wine:White )
wine:Riesling = wine:Wine ∩ (≤1 wine:madeFromGrape) ∩
                          (wine:madeFromGrape wine:RieslingGrape )
wine:Riesling ≤ wine:hasColor wine:White

wine:CorbansDryWhiteRiesling ∈ wine:Riesling ∩
                          (wine:hasMaker wine:Corbans) ∩ ...

Consequences of the Ontology Fragment

wine:Riesling ≤ wine:WhiteWine
wine:Riesling ≤ wine:WhiteWine ∩ (=1 wine:hasMaker)
wine:Riesling ≤ wine:WhiteWine ∩ (∀ wine:hasMaker wine:Winery)
wine:Riesling ≤ wine:WhiteWine ∪ (=7 wine:hasMaker)
wine:Riesling = wine:Riesling ∩ (wine:hasColor : wine:White)
wine:Riesling ∩ (wine:hasColor : wine:Red) ≤ wine:WineDescriptor
...
wine:CorbansDryWhiteRiesling ∈ wine:WhiteWine
wine:CorbansDryWhiteRiesling ∈ (wine:hasColor : wine:White) ∩
                          (wine:hasMaker : wine:Corbans)
...

What can be Done in OWL

Ontologies (An AI Approach)

What OWL Is

What OWL Is Not

What OWL Is Not

What OWL DL Is Not

How OWL Fits into the Web

How OWL Fits into the World Wide Web

How OWL Fits into the Semantic Web

Why You Should Give a Hoot About OWL

Influences on OWL

RDF

RDF Example

Exchange Syntax (RDF/XML) Abstract Syntax (RDF Graph)
<ex:Person:id="john"> john <rdf:type> <ex:Person>.
  <ex:name:datatype="&xsd;string"> john <ex:name>
    John Smith</ex:name>         "John Smith"^^xsd:string.
  <ex:spouse> john <ex:spouse> sally.
     <ex:Person:id="sally"> sally <rdf:type> <ex:Person>.
         <ex:father:resource="paul"/> sally <ex:father> paul.
    </ex:Person>
  </ex:spouse>
</ex:Person>
<rdf:description:about="#sally"> sally <ex:name>
  <ex:name:datatype="&xsd;string">         "Sally Brown"^xsd:string.
    Sally Brown</ex:name>
</rdf:description>

RDF Semantics

RDFS

RDFS Example

Information about the vocabulary in the previous example:

RDF and RDFS Summary

Description Logics

Description Logic Example

john ∈ Person ∩ name="John Smith"
<john,sally> ∈ spouse
Sally ∈ Person ∩ name="Sally Brown"
<sally,paul> ∈ father
spouse is symmetric
paul ∈ Person ∩ ≤ 0 spouse
Student ⊆ Person

Description Logic Inferences

john ∈ Person ∩ name="John Smith"
<john,sally> ∈ spouse
Sally ∈ Person ∩ name="Sally Brown"
<sally,paul> ∈ father
spouse is symmetric
paul ∈ Person ∩ ≤ 0 spouse
Student ⊆ Person

 
entails
 
sally ∈ Person ∩ ∃ spouse:Person
Student ∩ spouse:Student ⊆ Person ∩ spouse:Person
paul ∈ ∀ spouse : { sally }
mary ∈ (∀ spouse:Person ) ∪ (∃ spouse : ¬ { john } )

Determining Inference in DLs

(W3C) Design Criteria for OWL

  1. Part of the W3C Semantic Web
  2. Nice syntax, similar to frames
  3. Clean semantics, as for Description Logics
  4. Sufficiently expressive to represent many useful ontologies
  5. Suitable for implementations

No research needed because already done for DAML+OIL

Tensions in the Design

DAML+OIL

Is DAML+OIL the Answer?

Semantic Conformance (part 1)

OWL DL

OWL Lite

The Current Semantic Web Vision

Warning: This is my interpretation of the current instantiation of the semantic web vision in W3C based on various statements made by people associated with W3C.

Vision:
Specify meaning of constructs in the World-Wide Web so that computers can process and understand them
Implementation of ``process''
All information in the Semantic Web will be written in RDF
Implementation of ``understand''
All information in the Semantic Web will understandable as RDF

Why this Implementation of the Vision?

Effect of the Vision on OWL

Semantic Conformance (part 2)

Semantic Conformance (part 2)

Semantic Conformance (part 2)

The State of OWL

Going Forward

Can the Semantic Web vision be extended to the next (logic) level?

A New Implementation of the Vision

Vision:
Specify meaning of constructs in the World-Wide Web so that computers can process and understand them
Implementation of ``process''
All information in the Semantic Web will be written in RDFXML
Implementation of ``understand''
Everything in the Semantic Web will be a semantic extension of RDF(S)

A New Implementation of the Vision

Resources

DAML+OIL
http://www.daml.org/2001/03/daml+oil-index.html
OWL (W3C Web Ontology Working Group)
http://www.w3.org/2001/sw/WebOnt/
RDF (W3C RDF Core Working Group)
http://www.w3.org/2001/sw/RDFCore/