Peter F. Patel-Schneider, Bell Labs Research
Copyright © 2008 Bell Labs
OWL 1.1 is an update to OWL DL and is currently being considered by W3C for incorporation into a new W3C version of OWL. The original OWL was the result of a number of compromises and non-compromises between differing views of Knowledge Representation and the Semantic Web. OWL 1.1 takes differing stances on some of the issues underlying OWL, resulting in a need for rethinking the some of the design for the new OWL. In this talk, I will present the issues that underlie OWL and OWL 1.1 and present my views on how the should be resolved in the new W3C version of OWL (currently called OWL 2).
Namespace: = <http://ex.com/owl/families#>
Ontology: <http://ex.com/owl/families>
Import: <http://ex2.com/owl/family.owl>
ObjectProperty: hasWife
Annotations: rdfs:label "moglie"@it
Domain: Man Range: Woman
Characteristics: Functional,
Inverse Functional
SubPropertyOf: hasSpouse, loves
ObjectProperty: hasChild
Domain: Person Range: Person
SubPropertyOf: inverse hasAncestor
ObjectProperty: hasAncestor
Characteristics: Transitive
DataProperty: hasAge
Domain: Person Range: integer
Characteristics: Functional
Class: Person
SubClassOf:
hasAge exactly 1
and hasGender exactly 1
and hasGender only {female , male}
Class: Man
EquivalentTo:
Person that hasGender value male
Class: Parent
EquivalentTo:
Person that hasChild min 1
Class: YoungChild
EquivalentTo:
Person and
not (Teenager or Adult)
Individual: Jeff
Types: hasChild exactly 2
Facts: hasGender male,
hasWife Emily,
hasChild Ellen,
hasChild Jack,
hasAge 77,
loves Jeff
DifferentFrom:
Ellen, Jack, Susan, Emily
Individual: Emily
Types: hasAge some { 39 , 59 }
John rdf:type Person . Person rdf:type rdfs:Class .
treats Person as both a class and an object
(individual) John, and data
values, e.g., 5 and "string";
Jeff rdf:type _:t .
_:t rdf:type owl:Restriction .
_:t owl:onProperty hasChild .
_:t owl:cardinality "2"^^xsd:integer .
hasChild via
the owl:onProperty relationship
Person that hasChild min 3 Doctor)
ObjectProperty: hasWife
Characteristics: Irreflexive,
AntiSymmetric
ObjectProperty: hasDaughter
Domain: Parent
Range: Person that
hasGender value female
SubPropertyOf: hasChild
SuperPropertyOfChain:
f:hasSpouse o f:hasDaughter
ObjectProperty: hasSon
Domain: Parent
Range: Person that
hasGender value male
SubPropertyOf: hasChild
DisjointWith: hasDaughter
Class: Adult
Annotations: rdfs:label "adulto"@it
EquivalentTo:
Annotations: rdfs:comment
"This is a simple def of adult"
Person that
hasAge some integer[>= 21]
Class: Teenager
EquivalentTo: Person that
hasAge some integer[>= 13 , < 20]
Class: Narcissist
EquivalentTo: Person that
loves Self
Individual: Jeff
Types: hasChild exactly 2 Teenager
Individual: Ellen
Types: hasAge some integer[>= 15 , <= 19]
Individual: Jack
Facts: not hasAge "53"^^integer
Working group home page, http://www.w3.org/2007/OWL/wiki/OWL_Working_Group
Should be easy!
Several views of OWL and OWL 1.1:
Namespace: =<http://ex.com/owl/families#>
Namespace: g = <http://ex2.com/owl/family.owl#>
Namespace: families = <http://ex.com/owl/families#>
Namespace: rdfs = <http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#>
Namespace: rdf = <http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#>
Ontology: <http://ex.com/owl/families>
Import: <http://ex2.com/owl/family.owl>
ObjectProperty: hasWife
Domain: Person, Man
Range: Person, Woman
Characteristics: Functional, Inverse Functional, Irreflexive, AntiSymmetric
SubPropertyOf: hasSpouse, loves
ObjectProperty: hasHusband
Inverses: hasWife
ObjectProperty: hasSon
Domain: Person, Parent
Range: Person, Person that hasGender value male
SubPropertyOf: hasChild
DisjointWith: hasDaughter
SubObjectProperty: f:hasSpouse o f:hasSon f:hasSon **
ObjectProperty: hasDaughter
Domain: Person, Parent
Range: Person, Person that hasGender value female
SubPropertyOf: hasChild
SubObjectProperty: f:hasSpouse o f:hasDaughter f:hasDaughter **
ObjectProperty: hasGender
ObjectProperty: hasChild
Domain: Person Range: Person
SubPropertyOf: **INVERSEOF** hasAncestor
ObjectProperty: hasAncestor
Characteristics: Transitive, Irreflexive
ObjectProperty: hasSpouse
Characteristics: Symmetric, Irreflexive
ObjectProperty: loves
Domain: Person
DataProperty: hasAge
Domain: Person Range: integer
Characteristics: Functional
Class: Person
SubClassOf: hasAge exactly 1
and hasGender exactly 1
and hasGender only ({female , male})
Class: Man
EquivalentTo: Person that hasGender value male
Class: Woman
EquivalentTo: Person that hasGender value female
Class: Parent
EquivalentTo: Person that hasChild min 1
Class: Teenager
EquivalentTo: Person that hasAge some integer[>= 13 , < 20]
Class: Adult
EquivalentTo: Person that hasAge some integer[>= 21]
Class: Child
EquivalentTo: Person and not (hasAge some integer[>= 21])
Class: YoungChild
EquivalentTo: Person and not (Teenager or Adult)
Class: Marriage
EquivalentTo: CivilMarriage or ReligiousMarriage
Class: ReligiousMarriage
DisjointWith: CivilMarriage
Class: CivilMarriage
Class: Narcissist
EquivalentTo: Person that loves Self
Individual: male
DifferentFrom: female
Individual: female
Individual: John
Types: Person
Facts: hasWife Mary,
hasSon Bill,
hasDaughter Susan,
hasAge 33,
hasGender male
SameAs: Jack
DifferentFrom: Mary, Susan, Bill
Individual: Mary
Facts: hasSon Bill,
hasDaughter Susan,
hasAge 31,
hasGender female
Individual: Bill
Types: not (Narcissist)
Facts: hasAge 13,
hasGender male
Individual: Susan
Facts: hasAge 8,
hasGender female
Individual: Jeff
Types: hasChild exactly 2 Teenager
Facts: hasWife Emily,
hasChild Ellen,
hasChild Jack,
hasAge 77,
loves Jeff
DifferentFrom: Ellen, Jack, Susan, Emily
Individual: Emily
Types: hasAge some {39 , 49}
Individual: Ellen
Types: hasAge some integer[>= 15 , <= 21]
Individual: Jack
Facts: not hasAge "53"^^integer
SameIndividual: f:male g:masculine
SameIndividual: f:female g:feminine
EquivalentClasses: f:Adult g:Grownup
EquivalentObjectProperties: f:hasChild g:child
EquivalentDataProperties: f:hasAge g:age